When you buy through link on our site , we may bring in an affiliate commission . Here ’s how it works .
Unvaccinated the great unwashed currently account for most new cases of COVID-19 in the U.S. , but a little proportion of cases are in immunised masses ; these cases are known as breakthrough infections . But is there a difference in how often citizenry get breakthrough infections depending on which vaccine they induce ?
The short answer is , we do n’t know exactly , but there are some pinch in the data . The Johnson & Johnson vaccine does seem to have high rates of breakthrough contagion than the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines , but that was expected ground on the results of clinical tribulation . Some very early hints show a slightly depressed rate of breakthrough infections with the Moderna vaccinum than with the Pfizer vaccinum , but that former finding is based on data on a few million the great unwashed from only two locating and thus may not represent the overall picture in the commonwealth .
Related:5 dangerous myths about vaccine
Because no vaccine is 100 % effective , breakthrough infections have been expected from the offset of thevaccinerollout . In the linguistic context of clinical run , about0.04%of masses given the Pfizer vaccine got infected with SARS - CoV-2 , versus about0.07%with Moderna and0.59%with Johnson & Johnson .
Now that the vaccines are authorize , scientist have the opportunity to track how many breakthrough infections pass in the existent - humans , beyond clinical trial . When breakthroughs do occur , most hoi polloi feel meek symptom , if they descend ill at all , and a pocket-size share acquire dangerous disease , require hospitalization or die , current data point suggest .
The recent ascension of the extremely - transmissible delta variant might raise the risk of find infection , though . For example , a recent Centers for Disease Control and Prevention ( CDC ) work , published Aug. 6 as aMorbidity and Mortality Weekly Report(MMWR ) report , get that the delta variant surge in Mesa County , Colorado between May and June ; at the same clip , the county accrued a " significantly higher " dimension of breakthrough cases compared with other Colorado counties , where delta was less predominant .
Reporting of find infections now falls for the most part on the states , and of the 25 or so states that report breakthrough infection , most do n’t yet provide information on the bit of shell linked to each vaccine brand , Live Science found in a search of state health department websites .
However , Oklahoma and Washington , D.C. , do make this information public . These data could provide " former signal " regarding how well the vaccine are working , peculiarly as new edition emerge , the DC Health internet site posit . That said , there are many limitations : The data set are small , each vaccine was given to different numbers of people and the timing of the DoS makes it operose to interpret the datum .
Related : Coronavirus variant : Here ’s how the SARS - CoV-2 variation stack up
Still , as of Aug. 1 , more than 299,000 D.C. residents had been fully vaccinated , according todata from DC Health . Of these hoi polloi , nearly 151,000 get the two - dose Pfizer vaccine , about 124,700 got the two - dose Moderna vaccinum and about 24,000 received the one - back breaker Johnson & Johnson vaccine .
In this population , the highest pace of breakthroughs was see in those who got the Johnson & Johnson shot : 77 citizenry , or 0.32 % of the rough 24,000 recipients . The second highest rate was seen among Pfizer recipient role , of whom 308 masses , or 0.2 % , test plus for the virus . Finally , 161 , or 0.13 % , of the Moderna recipient caught a breakthrough infection .
These numbers include asymptomatic , modest , moderate and severe find cases . Some masses with asymptomatic or balmy infections may not get tested , so their cases would be omit , meaning this is probably an undercount of breakthroughs .
Related:20 of the worst epidemic and pandemic in story
Oklahoma has reported standardised results .
As of Aug. 2 , more than 1.5 million Oklahomans had been fully vaccinated , according to areport from the Oklahoma State Department of Health . About 817,000 had received Pfizer shots , 674,000 received Moderna and 102,000 got Johnson & Johnson . Again , the Johnson & Johnson recipients show the highest rate of breakthrough cases , with 215 , or 0.21 % , testing positivist for the virus ; 1,468 Pfizer recipient , or 0.17 % of the sum , caught a breakthrough contagion ; and 831 Moderna recipient role , or 0.12 % , tested electropositive for the virus .
— 11 ( sometimes ) deadly diseases that hopped across species
— 14 coronavirus myths bust by science
— The pernicious viruses in history
These snapshots from Oklahoma and D.C. likely volunteer an incomplete picture of breakthrough font in each region , however , and for now , it ’s unreadable if the observed design are representative of the state as a whole . To accurately compare the vaccine trade name , particularly with the delta variant still run rearing , we simply need more data , Robert Darnell , a doc scientist at The Rockefeller University in New York , toldNational Geographic .
That enjoin , other preliminary inquiry also suggests Moderna ’s vaccinum offers more aegis against the delta variant than Pfizer ’s , which could help explicate the differences in discovery rate , Reuters report . One report , station Aug. 8 on the preprint databasebioRxiv , included more than 50,000 patient in the Mayo Clinic Health System and found that the Moderna vaccine ’s real - world strength fall from 86 % to 76 % between January and July , when delta win prominence . In the same time windowpane , Pfizer ’s potency fall from 76 % to 42 % .
However , that study has not been peer - refresh yet , so the results still need to be confirmed .
Originally published on Live Science .
