Dating in a small town comes with its challenges — and drama.

“This is the story of five women in a small town where your dating app comes up empty after two swipes,” narratorHeather Grahamsays in the trailer.

‘Love in Fairhope’ narrator Heather Graham in New York City in June.Jamie McCarthy/Getty

Heather Graham attends “Suitable Flesh” premiere during the 2023 Tribeca Festival

Jamie McCarthy/Getty

“When it comes down to it, we all want the same thing: real, true love,” says Graham, 53.

Abby Mannich/Love in Fairhope is the first-of-its-kind real-life romantic drama, following five generations of women navigating life and love in the picturesque small town of Fairhope, Alabama

Dan Anderson/Hulu

Mannich, 33, returns to Fairhope after dreaming of living in the big city. She reconnects with her bad boy ex Trevor but doesn’t want to repeat her past mistakes and commits to a path of soul-searching.

“I love love,” Mannich declares in the trailer.

‘Love in Fairhope’ star Claiborne Walsh.Dan Anderson/Hulu

Claiborne Walsh/Love in Fairhope is the first-of-its-kind real-life romantic drama, following five generations of women navigating life and love in the picturesque small town of Fairhope, Alabama

Artist and poet Walsh, 76, finds herself widowed following 55 years of marriage. With the help of her single friends and daughter Aleen, she navigates modern dating in her 70s.

“I would like to find somebody that can make me laugh,” Walsh shares.

‘Love in Fairhope’ star LaShoundra Young.Dan Anderson/Hulu

LaShoundra Young/Love in Fairhope is the first-of-its-kind real-life romantic drama, following five generations of women navigating life and love in the picturesque small town of Fairhope, Alabama

Young, the town’s pastor’s wife, decides to divorce her husband Kendall because he made a few risky business decisions that impacted their family. Now the 41-year-old is settling into single motherhood and seeing if new love waits in Fairhope.

“I am afraid of being in a new relationship,” Young says in the trailer.

‘Love in Fairhope’ key art.Dan Anderson/ Hulu

Love in Fairhope Key Art

Dan Anderson/ Hulu

‘Love in Fairhope’ star Mya Jo Williams.Dan Anderson/Hulu

Mya Jo Williams/Love in Fairhope is the first-of-its-kind real-life romantic drama, following five generations of women navigating life and love in the picturesque small town of Fairhope, Alabama

Lastly, 32-year-old Ogletree, the daughter of town socialite and real estate mogul Paige Dawson, embarks a same-sex relationship with Tori after deciding to pursue starting a family on her own. Of course, her choices raise some eyebrows in the Bible Belt of America.

“The truth is, love is complicated,” Graham concludes in the trailer.

‘Love in Fairhope’ star Olivia Ogletree.Dan Anderson/Hulu

Olivia Ogletree/Love in Fairhope is the first-of-its-kind real-life romantic drama, following five generations of women navigating life and love in the picturesque small town of Fairhope, Alabama

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Love in Fairhopepremieres Sept. 27 on Hulu.

source: people.com