The worst thing about Star Wars : The Rise of Skywalkernot being universally belovedis it makes masses require “ What if ? ” What if other decisions had been made ? Could the movie have been better ? These kind of interrogation find natural with this motion picture in particular because Colin Trevorrow , the original director and co - writer , bequeath the projectyears before it was liberate .
In the daytime since the liberation of The Rise of Skywalker , that ’s become abig topic of speculationamong fans . What did the movie calculate like when Trevorrow , who’d been working on the projectfor over two years , give in 2017 ? Normally that ’s not something we ’d feel out , but at least one person claim they know .
That mortal is film producer Robert Meyer Burnett . Burnett , who directed theStar Trek - theme picture show Free Enterprise , went on his YouTube show , Robservations , and over the course of two Day detail an entire script he believes was written by Trevorrow and Derek Connolly and completed on December 16 , 2016 . That hand was send for Star Wars Episode IX : Duel of the Fates .
It always comes down to Rey and Kylo.Photo: (Disney)
https://gizmodo.com/io9s-guide-to-all-the-movies-you-should-give-a-damn-abo-1840780568
io9 contacted Disney to expect about the handwriting , but the studio does not comment on hearsay or speculation and once again would n’t in this lawsuit . We also reached out to Lucasfilm specifically but had not heard back at the time of publishing , and when contacted , Trevorrow ’s theatrical performance had no comment . That means , as of now , no one has confirm or denied the veracity of Burnett ’s title . If that change , we ’ll update this story .
As for Burnett , he does n’t say on his show where he got this script , nor does he technically sustain he really has a copy of the script ( even though on the show , he ’s clearly read from some kind of varan ) . What he does say though is as follows : “ I do n’t bed if it ’s real but I really believe that it is . I conceive with all my heart it ’s a material script because one , it ’s a really well - write screenplay , and two , it ’s too secure to be artificial . ” We address to multiple sources with knowledge of the situation and they either claim that the hand is real or at the very least that Burnett is well - connect enough in Hollywood that he could have procured it . Our friend at theAV Clubhave also independently confirmed the genuineness .
Rey takes a new path in Duel of the Fates.Photo: (Disney)
If we go by those sources and usurp it ’s legit , the first thing to observe is that date of December 16 , 2016 . That ’s crucially important because it’s11 day before the deathof Carrie Fisher . Duel of the Fates was then written under the effrontery Fisher could play a prominent theatrical role in it , which she does . Her departure , as we know , was not justa gas for fans everywhere , but the mass get this movie . It touch on the counseling of the story greatly andJ.J. Abrams himself has tell as much . December 2016 was also a yearbefore the release ofThe Last Jedi , so any idea of what fan would think of the selection in that plastic film was still a long style away . All of which is to say , Duel of the Fates , in this form , was still comparatively far from being what even Trevorrow could have put on screen .
All of this first came to lightin a Reddit postwhere fans began discussing Burnett ’s claims . However , that Wiley Post only manage with Monday ’s instalment of Burnett ’s show . On Tuesday , he was back and provided more detail , specifically on the ending . If you want to read a detailed crack-up of the flick ’s intro and 2d act , you could do so on that Reddit berth , or you canwatch the full telecasting . We ’re just going to verbalize about the oddment of the movie as revealed on Tuesday ’s episode , which can be watched here .
In the purported script , Burnett says Rey and Kylo Ren meet on Mortis — the infamous planet first go steady in the third season of Clone Wars . It ’s a nexus of the Living Force and home to cryptic beingness encounter by Ahsoka , Anakin , and Obi - Wan who incarnate the light , sullen , and cosmic constituent of the Force itself .
Kylo gets redeemed, but not as much, in Duel of the Fates.Photo: (Disney)
Mortis , Rey and Ren believe , is the lineage of the Living Force , a place where they ’ll find reply . And of course , a huge lightsaber battle ensues , with Rey trying to quit Kylo from get into one of the synagogue there . During the conflict , Kylo slash Rey across the face , she flow down some stair , and he pull up stakes her for all in . Kylo perish into the temple only to find … it ’s empty . There ’s nothing there . At this moment , Luke’sForce Ghostshows up ( yes , in 2016 Trevorrow and Connolly were apparently ferment under the premiss that Luke died ) and gives a last - ditch movement to turn him . During his lecture , Rey plunk herself up but has been blinded . Nevertheless , she puts something over her eyes and races back to confront Kylo .
“ Our masters were wrong , ” Rey said . “ I will not deny my wrath . I will not reject my love . I am the darkness and I am the light . ”
“ You ’re nothing . You ’re no one , ” Kylo responds . Rey then ignites her lightsaber and says “ No one is no one ” before run at him , and the battle continues . The line , according to Burnett , is a callback to in the beginning in the film when Rey is talk about her descent with Poe and he explains that everyone is who they desire to be . No one is no one .
You were always going to win, Rey.Photo: (Disney)
Rey , now embracing the light and the dark , gains a whole new level of power , slashes at Kylo ’s hand , severs his fingers , and destroys his lightsaber . “ There ’s an unfathomable Living Force within her , ” the playscript state . However , earlier in the motion picture , Kylo had watch the unnatural power to steal the Living Force from beings and starts to do that to Rey . She ca n’t handle it . Kylo is mend and he ’s about to bring home the bacon . Just then , he hear the call of his mother , expect him to come home . Kylo gives in and gives Rey her life essence back , but in the cognitive process begins to pass himself . In his last breath , he reveals her genuine name : Rey Solana . ( I recollect that ’s the spelling , ground on hear it . Also of note , Kylo knows this because he ’s the one who killed Rey ’s parents in this version . He used to kill Force - tender kids for Snoke , who is also not in this script , which makes good sense pay The Last Jedi , and had tracked down Rey years ago . She escaped . Her parents did n’t . )
So Kylo is all in , Rey is alert , but just hardly . She then ascends to a higher plane of beingness and run into the Force Ghosts of Obi - Wan , Yoda , and Luke . “ Taught us much you have , ” Yoda says to Rey . Rey is disordered . “ Succeeded where we have failed . Narrow was our stop of vista , ” he says . “ You chose to squeeze the dark side and the light . To find the symmetry within , ” says Luke . “ Co - exist they must , ” say Yoda . “ As such feelings do in all of us . ”
In a very Harry Potter - esque second , Rey is then faced with a choice : delay in this blank space and win enlightenment , or go back to the domain of the living , which will be harsh , but she ’ll be live . As she thinks about it Obi - Wan leaves her with one final thought , “ You are a Jedi , Rey Solana . But you will not be the last . ” This whole verbal description is from about1:35 minutes into Burnett ’s show through about 1:44 .
Meanwhile , as this is fall out , the big battle between the Resistance and the First Order is happening on and aroundCoruscant . During the combat , R2 - D2 is brutally damaged but Chewbacca put the parts on his back and continues to fight . After the Rey and Force Ghosts scene , the film switch off back to Coruscant place - victory . Chewbacca , Leia , C-3PO , and others are putting R2 back together and reminisce . The final objet d’art of the puzzle is to reinstall his computer memory savings bank which Leia herself does , in a pose reminiscent of A New Hope . When she does , R2 ’s memory start up to construct itself and , as that ’s come about , all of those memories start projecting themselves . Sixty years of struggle all from R2 ’s perspective . Which basically terminate up being a nine - episode Star Wars highlight spool , something Trevorrowhad hinted at way back in 2016 .
From there , the final scene of the motion-picture show remove place on a planet call in Modesta ( probably a wink to the place of origin of George Lucas , Modesto , California ) . Finn is there with a bunch of kids and Rey get , quick to train the next generation of Jedi . Roll credits .
Two other sport sidebar from the end of the photographic film . The First Order loses , in part , because its HQ on Coruscant is a elephantine ship . During the conflict Rose Tico ( who has a much larger part in this version of Episode IX ) rewire their hyperdrive so that when the headquarters taste to forget , it ends up crash into a major planet . Also , before that , Hux also has a great death picture . Apparently a working jest in the script is that he observe trying to use the Force to compete with Kylo . When he realize the First Order is finished , he goes into his chambers and we encounter out he ’s a secret Jedi wonk and has been collecting lightsabers . He lights one up and uses it to become flat by suicide .
There ’s so , so much more too from earlier in the movie — and , again , if you ’re interested , I exhort you to go and take heed to both of Burnett ’s shows . They ’re long and a small suck - out but over the two videos he explain so much more of what this moving picture might have been . And they may be the close thing we ever get to their realisation .
Again , that ’s if this is handwriting is existent . Would seeing what we discover here have been cool ? Yes . good than what we got ? For some , perhaps . in the end it would ’ve fare down to execution , and there ’s no guarantee it would have played out on screen as it does in your question reading these description . There ’s also no indicant , at all , that this script is universally “ better ” than what we got . It ’s just … dissimilar . And , in the closing , none of this matter . This is not the script that was made ; if it ’s reliable , it ’s a playfulness piece of trivia and that ’s all that it is . She ’s not Rey Solana . She ’s Rey Skywalker , a descendant ofSheev Palpatine . And love it or detest it , that ’s what it is .
If anything , Burnett ’s reappraisal of Duel of the Fates is a will to the incredible talent and effort the team at Lucasfilm have developing these movies as well as a potential window into the appendage . If this script is real , it ’s test copy that there was more than a little communication going on during the ontogeny of all three movies . This script knows Luke was dead . It live Snoke was bushed . And the castanets of it — Kylo ’s lookup for force from a high being , a message reuniting the Resistance , Force healing — are what J.J. Abrams and Chris Terrio used to make their pic , which is why Trevorrow and Connolly got tale credit entry .
The Rise of Skywalker is an evolution of these ideas , not a reset .
For more , make certain you ’re follow us on our Instagram @io9dotcom .
disneyJJ AbramsLUCASFILMStar Wars
Daily Newsletter
Get the good tech , scientific discipline , and culture news in your inbox daily .
News from the future , deliver to your present .
You May Also Like
